A federal judge has handed Apple a win, ruling to toss a $308.5 million patent infringement verdict because of an underlying scheme to extract more money from companies.
The case centered on a patent for digital rights management technology owned by Personalized Media Communications (PMC), which first sued Apple in 2015. Earlier in 2021, a federal jury decided that Apple should owe $308.5 million in royalties to the firm.
However, U.S. District Judge Rodney Gilstrap has tossed that verdict, Bloomberg reported Friday. Gilstrap ruled that PMC patent wasn’t enforceable because the company intentionally delayed its application so that it could extract more royalties from technology companies.
PMC’s patents date back to applications filed in the ’80s. At the time, the terms of a patent lasted 17 years no matter how long the application process took. The company filed for numerous patents in the ’80s and ’90s, but none were awarded until 2010.
To reach his decision, Gilstrap relied on a June ruling from a top patent court that made it easier for companies to challenge “submarine patents.” The tactic revolves around patent applicants delayed issuance of a patent until an industry adopted the technology. In other words, it’s a scheme to ensure that patent infringement lawsuits would be more profitable.
“The course of conduct undertaken by PMC constitutes an unreasonable delay and an abuse of the statutory patent system,” Gilstrap wrote.
According to internal company documents reviewed by Gilstrap, PMC carried out a strategy to ensure patents wouldn’t be issued until infringement became widespread in the technology industry. A 1991 document specifically named Apple among “natural candidates” for being hit by the scheme.
The original lawsuit, first filed in 2015, took aim at Apple’s FairPlay software, which is used to ensure DRM on content from iTunes, the App Store, and Apple Music.
AppleInsider has affiliate partnerships and may earn commission on products purchased through affiliate links. These partnerships do not influence our editorial content.
$308.5!
Oh, Snap! Couldn’t have happened to a more deserving patent troll! 😂
Patent trolling hurts consumers. Consumers win when the legal system recognizes the difference between a patent troll and valid stolen ideas. Every single company from Apple to Google to your chosen auto company to your appliance maker has built into their pricing, that we! pay, the price of defense to patent trolling and lawsuits on almost every product that occurs (they troll for technicalities in ToS or gray area designs). On this second one we consumers also pay because companies must fight everything.
Good! We need more of this. You should not be able to lay a patent trap.
Patent & Copyright laws have been abused for too long
An increasing number of iTunes Match users are reporting issues with the service, with some claiming content uploads have not been functional for weeks.
A number of Apple Music, App Store, and iTunes users encountered issues with the online services on July 31, problems Apple was aware of and rectified quickly.
Microsoft co-founder Bill Gates was caught off guard with the launch and structure of Apple’s iTunes Store in 2003, with Apple co-founder Steve Jobs once again putting Gates in catch-up mode, according to an internal email that surfaced this week.
Apple may have market dominance with its AirPods Pro, but neither AirPods Pro nor the new Beats Studio Buds can match the luxurious build quality of Master & Dynamic’s new MW08 Sport true wireless earbuds.
With the launch of the Beats Studio Buds, Apple now has a total of four wireless earbuds it sells to consumers. Here’s how the newcomers face against AirPods, AirPods Pro, and Beats Powerbeats Pro.
Sony launched the WF-1000XM4 wireless earbuds in June, its noise-cancelling rival to the Apple AirPods Pro. Here’s how Sony’s latest stacks up against Apple’s heavy hitter.
Apple has evolved its remote control over time, with each iteration introducing physical improvements and better features. After launching the second-generation Siri Remote, has Apple created its best controller?
In April, Amazon upgraded its Echo Buds to make it a better value-oriented rival to Apple’s AirPods. Here’s how Amazon’s offerings stack up to Apple’s AirPods and AirPods Pro.
